Skip to main content

Parshat Chayei Sarah - 5780 "Change your Life in Ten Minutes"

Change Your Life in 10 Minutes
 Chayei Sarah 5780

 Rabbi Shaanan Gelman with Rabbi Ariel Rackovsky
Several years ago, I visited the site of the Wannsee Conference, the infamous event in which, over the span of two hours, the elite of the Nazi Party formulated the plan for the extermination of 6,000,000 of our brethren.  After touring the room in which the worst atrocity in history was born, I stepped outside, overwhelmed by the gravity of what I had just ingested - and our group realized that it was nearly time to daven mincha.  In a few more minutes the sun would set and we would lose the opportunity.  We had the numbers to form a quorum, that was not our problem, the only question which plagued us was whether it was appropriate to pray at the location of such pure evil?  We further realized that in order to face east, we would have to stand facing the cursed structure while reciting the amida.  After a few moments of uncomfortable debate, we recognized that we had no choice, and if anything, this mincha prayer would be our little victory celebration...I closed my eyes, took three steps back and then forward again, I uttered the words “כִּי שֵׁם האֶקְרָא הָבוּ גֹדֶל לֵאלֹהֵינוּ
And was transported from the outskirts of Berlin, to Israel, into Jerusalem and over the walls of the Kotel haMaaravi, where I would spend the next 5 to 10 minutes in exalted communion with Hashem.  Who would have guessed that a tiny little afternoon service could be the most memorable and transformative part of such a day!

Long before my powerful and transformative mincha experience, our patriarch, Yitzchak was the very first person to daven mincha. The Torah sets the scene. The complicated negotiations leading to the shidduch between Yitzchak and Rivka have concluded,  and all that is left is for the happy couple to meet. Rivka travels with Eliezer, and she draws near astride a camel, festooned with jewels. No doubt she is anxious to meet the man she has pledged to marry. Will he be kind and generous? Will he be communicative? Will he be a good parent? The Torah says precious little about Yitzchak, and his preparation for this fateful meeting. As the caravan approaches, Rivka sees a solitary figure off in the distance, oblivious to his surroundings, lost in holy devotion. ויצא יצחק לשוח בשדה לפנות ערב

This is not the first time Yitzchak seems disengaged. Consider that at every pivotal moment in his life, Yitzchak played a passive role. The Akeida saw him bound helplessly on the altar, as his father hovered ominously above him.  He did nothing to secure his status as his father’s spiritual heir; instead, his mother did the heavy lifting, casting his half-sibling Yishmael into the barren desert[1]. Nor did he have to sacrifice anything to live in Eretz Canaan, where he lived his entire life without interruption.  And later, as blessings are to be given to his children, he is a mere pawn in the scheme orchestrated by his wife Rivka. Everything in Yitzchak’s life was either done to him, for him, or despite him.  At this moment, we’d expect something different. Eliezer could bring the young woman, but he had to, at the very least, show up on the date! The absurdity of this scenario becomes obvious when updated somewhat, and made a little more contemporary. Picture a stunning young woman about to go on a date. She has spent an hour deciding which outfit to wear and which makeup to apply. She arrives at the restaurant where they’ve decided to meet, and she sees her date. He looks in her direction, and the first thing he does is daven Mincha. Really? Now he starts to daven?
בראשית פרק כד פסוק סג
וַיֵּצֵ֥א יִצְחָ֛ק לָשׂ֥וּחַ בַּשָּׂדֶ֖ה לִפְנ֣וֹת עָ֑רֶב
EVen more surprising to the reader is that when Yitzchak lifts his head out of the siddur to take notice of his future wife - he notices the irrelevant details - the camels!
 וַיִּשָּׂ֤א עֵינָיו֙ וַיַּ֔רְא וְהִנֵּ֥ה גְמַלִּ֖ים בָּאִֽים:

Yitzchak has done literally nothing to secure this Shidduch. All he needs to do is look up, and say “hello.” Why is he davening now? This question is especially strong when you consider that Mincha was a voluntary service at the time, and not an obligation.  
Maybe the Torah, in telling us this detail, is stressing the significance of the Mincha prayer, and maybe it was Yitzchak’s way of preparing for marriage and building a home. 
In order to understand why, we must remember that Yitzchak’s meeting with Rivka was not the only significant biblical event associated with Mincha. Many hundreds of years later, on the top of Mt. Carmel, Eliyahu HaNavi conducted a showdown with the false prophets of Baal, whose empty promises and hedonistic rituals held sway over the hearts of so many wayward Jews. Many of us remember the denouement of the story, with God’s heavenly fire descending to consume Eliyahu’s offerings. But what we don’t usually recall from the story is perhaps the most critical detail:
מלכים א פרק יח פסוק לו
וַיְהִ֣י׀ בַּעֲל֣וֹת הַמִּנְחָ֗ה
The confrontation took place as Eliyahu calls out to God during Mincha time. Our sages were quick to pick up on this detail.
ברכות ו:
אמר רבי חלבו אמר רב הונא: לעולם יהא אדם זהיר בתפלת המנחה, שהרי אליהו לא נענה אלא בתפלת המנחה.
Rav Chelbo said in the name of Rav Huna, a person should always exercise great care in praying Mincha, because Eliyahu was only answered during the Mincha service. What is it about Mincha that is so propitious? I’d like to suggest three reasons.

First, mincha is an opportunity to perform an act of chessed for others. Here at KCT, we have people join us for davening from literally all over the world, coming here on business and looking for a minyan to say Kaddish. Anyone who takes time from their day to join a minyan for  Mincha is not only fulfilling their mandate בין אדם למקום, but also a sanctified form of בין אדם לחבירם. Mincha minyanim often gather a motley crew of people, from vastly different backgrounds, all united for the same purpose. It is a great privilege to be a part of such an assemblage.

Second, Mincha challenges us to remember that we are Jews. In the days of Eliyahu, the Jews felt they could worship both God and the Ba’al. The fateful moment on Har HaCarmel was when Eliyahu challenged them, “How much longer will you straddle the fence? Either pick God, or pick Ba’al!” Mincha is the prayer you utter to show that we live in one world, not two. It is the only prayer that asks you to peel away from the other commitments in your world. The Tur (OC 232) articulates this idea beautifully. Shacharit is prayed at the beginning of the day, before you leave for work or whatever other endeavors the day will bring. Maariv is prayed at the end, when the phone has stopped ringing and when you begin winding down your day. The time for Mincha, however, begins shortly after midday, and particularly during the winter months, requires us to determine whether we are Jews during work, on vacation or in the middle of the Bears game.
טור אורח חיים הלכות תפלת המנחה סימן רלב
הלכות תפלת המנחה:
….והטעם מפני שתפלת השחר זמנה ידוע בבקר בקומו ממטתו יתפלל מיד קודם שיהא טרוד בעסקיו וכן של ערב בלילה זמנה ידוע בבואו לביתו והוא פנוי מעסקיו אבל של מנחה שהיא באמצע היום בעוד שהוא טרוד בעסקיו צריך לשום אותה אל לבו ולפנות מכל עסקיו ולהתפלל אותה ואם עשה כן שכרו הרבה מאד וע"כ מנעו חכמים לכל אדם לעשות מלאכות הקבועות סמוך לזמן המנחה דתנן לא ישב אדם לפני הספר פי' להסתפר סמוך למנחה עד שיתפלל ולא יכנס למרחץ ולא לבורסקי ולא לדין ולא לאכול
Nowadays, it is not difficult- especially in larger communities- to find workplace mincha minyanim.  In our community, there are at least a dozen, and there is even a 2 PM Mincha at the Yeshiva hosted in our shul. In several places, the Agudah publishes a Mincha Minyan directory, and on godaven.com you can find listings for the nearest Mincha minyan anywhere in the world. This was not always the case. In May 1977, the New Yorker[2]  ran a profile of the legendary Chabad chossid Reb Leibel Bistritzky, who owned a dairy store on the Lower East Side. Reb Leibel was a pioneer of many Jewish initiatives in New York- he was one of the first members of Hatzoloh, for example. But what he was best known for was that which the New Yorker wrote about. Every single day, at 4 PM, he would close his tiny store for 10 minutes for a Mincha minyan. It didn’t matter how many customers were in it, and how many were waiting to be served. A neighboring proprietor, Meilech Torn- co-owner of H&M Skullcap- said, in his interview-
It can rain, it can snow, it can lightning- there’s Mincha at Bistritzky’s...He’s a man with a soul. Nobody else would do it- close a store when he has twenty customers. If it weren’t for him, a lot of Jews wouldn’t be praying. So when he calls, we answer.”
Most of us won’t have the same level of impact on the broader Jewish community that Leibel Bistritzky did.  We won’t be a founding member of Hatzoloh and we won’t be proprietors of iconic food establishments. But like Leibel, we can all be mincha yidden.

Finally, in taking a break from the day and fulfilling our prayer obligations, we are not just declaring that we are Jews. We are also declaring what kind of Jews we are. Rav Eliezer Melamed, he great posek of the religious Zionist community and Rosh Yeshiva of the Har Beracha Yeshiva, writes[3] that mincha challenges us to take whatever it is we are doing and to uncover the Divine dimension within.

His understanding of the role of tefilat mincha encourages us to take stock of our entire day, and ask, what have we have done to sanctify it?  If I enaged in a casual conversation over lunch, was it part of my day as an eved Hashem?  If you watch a movie- even a “kosher” one- can you find the two or three lessons that may inform the way in which we conduct ourselves as moral and righteous Jews[4]?
This challenges us to live the kind of life in which it’s easy to connect the dots, that nothing we did throughout our days should be viewed as separate from the overall mission of our lives. Praying Mincha retroactively sanctifies the day and shows that everything we did fits into that holy framework- or at least ought to.
These two approaches to tefilat mincha echo the two interpretations of the word מנחה.  It means menucha – or rest, an oasis away from the madness of the rest of your day.  It also comes from the word מָנְחה , meaning “director/leader” as in שמות יג:יז:
וְלֹא-נָחָם אֱלֹהִים דֶּרֶךְ אֶרֶץ פְּלִשְׁתִּים, כִּי קָרוֹב הוּא: 
that God led them not by the way of the land of the Philistines, although that was near;

Mincha interrupts what we are doing, to introduce a little קודש into the חול, and it informs the rest of our day that it is meant to be קודש as well.  We have the ability to stop what we are doing and initiate something exalted and moreover we can transport ourselves for ten blessed minutes to another world – you aren’t in work, you are engaging the Almighty, you aren’t standing in the cursed grounds of Berlin, you are in Yerushalayim Ir Hakodesh!
It’s no wonder that at the most pivotal moments of Yitzchak and Eliyahu’s lives, they carved out a few moments to recite the most overlooked prayer of our day. Let us use their example and take time out from our day for the same purpose.





[1] Contrast this with Yaakov who must confront Esav directly throughout his life
[3] Pninei Halacha- Hilchot Tefillah
[4] Nietzsche said that if you look back on your life and contemplate the 5 or so moments you really felt alive, then connect the dots, drawing an imaginary line - you will find your life’s purpose - why cant do this each day, connect the dots - at Mincha we connect the dots

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Rambam - Hilchot Avodat Kochavim v'Chukoteiheim

Rambam - Hilchot Avodat Kochavim v'Chukoteiheim Part 1 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/2987410858051525 Part 2 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/2993568554102422 Part 3 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/3044240482368562 Part 4 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/3211019505690658/ Part 5 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/3232417076884234/

Rambam - Hilchot Deot

  Rambam, Mishneh Torah - Hilchot Deot Hilchot Deot_1 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/2780940378698575/ Hilchot Deot_2 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/2789988654460414/ Hilchot Deot_3 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/2792170630908883/ Hilchot Deot_4 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/2796818433777436/ Hilchot Deot_5 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/2805696462889633/ Hilchot Deot_6 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/2808056329320313/ Hilchot Deot_7 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/2822058594586753/ Hilchot Deot_8 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/2824488121010467/ Hilchot Deot_9 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/2827074084085204/ Hilchot Deot_10 https://www.facebook.com/shaanan.gelman/videos/2829642670495012/

Parshat Ekev - 5779 - "Red Herring Judaism"

Parshat Ekev - 5779 “Red Herring Judaism” Rabbi Shaanan Gelman and Rabbi Ariel Rackovsky Rabbi Yaakov Bienenfeld, Rabbi of the Young Israel of Harrison in Westchester, is a legendary Rebbe who taught at the Ramaz Upper School for over two decades. A number of years ago, the students were awaiting a visit from a certain prominent Rebbe or Rosh Yeshiva in an Israeli Torah institution.   As a show of respect, a delegation of students was stationed by the door to greet the esteemed guest. The Rabbi - who was wearing slacks, a blue oxford and a kippah seruga, passed by the students unnoticed and headed immediately up to the office, to prepare for his address to the student body and for the interviews he was about to conduct for his post High School program. Meanwhile, at around the same time, another man showed up, with a long beard, flowing payos and a long frock coat and hat. Instantly, the students ushered him into the assembly and broke out into ecstatic song, אור זרוע לצד